Every Republican under the sun, it seems, wants the Queen to apologise for the whole enchilada from Strongbow’s invasion of Ireland and the manky spud famine to Bloody Sunday (Part I & Part II). But won’t Elizabeth Windsor suffer enough faced with a barrage of Irish c’lebs from Amanda Brunker to Lorraine Keane − whose contribution to Irish culture has been to tell motorists to avoid the Kimmage crossroads during rush hour − to the bats-in-the-belfry yodels of Mary Byrne and the self piteous whines of a NAMA property developer? I’m assuming that Jedward will also be present, kickboxing at the cameras, demanding acreage of attention.
One group definitely not invited to the Royal hooley are those knockabout funsters in the Real IRA. They recently described the Queen’s 3-day junket as ‘the final insult’. Yet privately they’re probably salivating over the prospect of international broadcast attention from CNN, Sky News, NBC, and the BBC as they attempt to disrupt a blue-rinse pensioner lobbing some dried flowers on some very dead people in gardens normally occupied by Whacker, Thrasher, Basher and Redser, with their Nike logbags full of hypodermic needles and Druids cider.
To be serious for a moment though: after the national revulsion over Constable Ronan Kerr’s murder the dissies have now been gifted a chance of a propaganda-comeback. If they can turn parts of Dublin upside down as they did with the Love Ulster rally in 2006 they will score a publicity coup. The sight of globally renowned correspondents reporting live on the violence in Parnell St. will put the dissidents inflexibly back on the map. RSF has already announced their main demo starts at the Black Church behind Parnell Square (one time home to other dummies of a wax variety) where no doubt the track suit catwalk will charge like wildebeest towards a line of red-faced culchie Gardaí who’d give their left scrotum to be off-duty milling about with a Hurley stick somewhere bovine-deep in the midlands.
Security operations so far have involved a lot of Garda knocking on a lot of doors and ‘taking people’s names’ like they used to do back in the day of Garda Patrol (precursor to Crimecall) when a random Mrs Murphy’s garden gate was stolen. A pal who lives on Clonliffe Road backing onto Croke Park, which is part of Lizzy’s barnstorm, described how a country Guard knocked at her door and asked for her name and address. The name bit she could partially understand, but the address bit was a puzzle as he’d just knocked on her door after all! Bins have been confiscated, phone boxes soldered shut, student accommodation evacuated, sewers searched (perhaps even members of the voluntary Garda Reserve are manning the city drains and sewers?) All around Parnell Square the polished-bróga Special Branch have been not very discreetly placing sniper folk on sagging Edwardian rooftops in what I assume is an attempt to outwit other snipers belonging to more bothersome organisations who are way better at the gun thing and with more reason to use them. My bet is that an unemployed INLA man, unable to get onto a FÁS scheme due to the upsurge in quantity surveyors and solicitors hogging places, will send some bullets flying into the air, causing untold hysteria and horror, perhaps even a right royal stampede with Lizzy roaring, “Help! Help! My hat!” and De Duke saying: “Oh shit I say, here we go again old girl”.
The Twitter has been groaning with protestations all week: ‘What’s this about school children being drafted in to wave flags for queen’s visit? A reprehensible misuse of children,’ says Greystones branch of Sinn Féin. ‘Would ya really go on holiday to a place where the majority of the population want to see your head on a pike?’ asks another.
The tour is too long and is tempting fate. Already there are hoax bombs (London: yesterday, Maynooth and Inchicore Luas, this morning) and various ‘designed to disrupt’ shenanigans. There are too many venues and the opportunities are large for something to go badly wrong. Contrast with Obama who has just two venues to speak at before heading back into the burly blue sky. It would’ve been better if the Queen had tea & a few slices of McCambridges bread with Mary McAleese at Aras, followed by symbolic tree planting in the park, a pint of black stuff at Guinness Brewery and down to some stud farm in Kildare (where they’re all West Brits anyway) before heading back to Blighty. To put further blue fuel on verdigris flames, the geniuses in the Phoenix Park Gaff have invited UDA supremo Jackie McDonald and his loyalist entourage to Golden Bridge for the war dead ceremony. It’s a Tiramisu of farce, every day new and more flavoursome layers added.
Ireland, in the shitpit of fiscal smelliness, is forking out a fragrant €30 million to protect the Queen’s head and the Duke of Edinburgh’s torso (Philip’s uncle was blown up here). Costs could rise excessively if riots do erupt and British holiday-makers are scared off by the Queen’s getaway to the Emerald Isle ending in calamity. Fianna Fáil gambled and lost the banking industry through their disastrous 2008 bailout. Now, Fine Gael and Labour are gambling on one of the few businesses left in our economically ravaged country: tourism. Remember too that this prodigious PR stunt was planned as the final chapter in a long drawn-out peace process. However, if things go awry it could be the preface to an upsurge in Republican conflict all over again.
This is the biggest test of authority for the state since the 1981 hunger strike riots outside the British Embassy. The entire thing will be a sphincter-squeezing moment even if 10,000 strapping Guards, army and all 17 members of Special Branch manage to block the view of rampaging animals at the barricades. It will be like one of those icy moments out of sight in a Titanic lifeboat, where even from a polite distance there’s scant hope of drowning out the howls. The only good thing that could possibly happen if disaster strikes is Tonight with Vincent Browne would be forced to change topic, if only for a week.
June Caldwell is a writer, who after 13 years of journalism, is finally writing a novel. She has a MA in Creative Writing and was winner of ‘Best Blog Post’ award at the 2011 Irish Blog Awards. You can read this post on her own blog here:

Why did they send Betty 2, very symbol of Empire, when they could’ve sent Peter Crouch, Del Boy, Twiggy, someone from Coronation Street, or one of so many YouKay representatives whom we’d all have been delighted to welcome (except for three people and they’d be all talking Early Middle Irish so we wouldn’t understand them anyway)? Never mind sending the gracious queen, send the people.
Most enjoyable piece I’ve read on this topic.
Cheers!
Very good post. I think the Queen has great guts coming here if you consider how real the threat is to her – after all she’s an old lady.
While your predictions at the end might be a bit doomsday there is absolutely no doubt that any kind of negative result to this would be the last nail in our coffin as a modern, peaceful country. Here’s hoping the numbskulls in the dissident groups can be contained.
Totally agree with you but I’m nervous/cynical for a reason. I don’t trust those ‘uns at all. I don’t think there’ll be anything truly dramatic (we’ve been sucking the UK coffers dry as well Europe’s, so money always talks) but I do think people in general here underestimate the professionalism (wrong word maybe) and determination of dissident groups. I’m cringeing already.
Great piece! LOVE the Gardai knocking on someone’s door and asking their address. LOVE that bit. (I know that isn’t the main thrust of your piece, but I loved that bit!)
I really hope this visit goes well, and I have no moral objection to her visting, but I can’t wait until she goes home. Which I think is a terrible thing to say. I’ve never wished for any other head of state to go home. Obama can stay as long as he likes, we’ve have other presidents and prime ministers here before and it’s barely made an impact. But I just can’t help thinking something awful is going to happen and the sooner she’s gone the better.
I know what you mean! I’m looking forward to the ‘see ye, do call again’ moment. I think the visit is a mistake at this time.
Very amusing piece, a great read to start the day. Personally I don’t have an issue with the Queen’s visit. If I got the chance, I would go to see her. It is an historic occasion. But I do worry about what could happen.
This is an opportunity for us to show what Ireland has to offer and that we have matured, instead of being the “messers down the back” of the European classroom.
If something does go wrong, it can’t be undone, and will reflect so badly on us. The Queen is 85. She is the utmost professional (in a job that should never have fallen on her in the first place). Not everyone has to agree with the institution that is the British monarchy but I think we should have respect for others and let the visit come and go undisturbed.
It’s amazing she’s 85! She has better physicality than me and can walk better…she did a lot of strolling about on her jaunts today. I was cringeing watching the Garden of Remembrance coverage, expecting anything, but I’m amazed there were only 8 arrests. And the Shinners released 1,000 black balloons into the air whatever that’s supposed to symbolise? Impressive stuff (so far). Not much happened at all around Parnell Square though Moore Street was crammed full of human bulldogs. The 20 guests at Aras were somewhat of a puzzle: Rachel Allen? I wonder did she hand lizzy one of her autographed O’Brien sambos…
Brilliant! Really enjoyed reading. Thank you
Personally, I think its hilarious that a ‘sign of our maturity’ will be measured against spending €30m protecting an 85 year old lady
Call me old fashioned…! Do you have a point of view?
No Charlie. Of course I’ve no point of view.
30 million quid wasted, private homes and private citizens searched. Lanes on the motorways closed off for days, parks and the zoo closed, public transport affected, cycle stations closed.
I’ve no moral objection to the queen visiting this country, but come on. 30 million? while we losing teaching assistants left right and centre and thinking of selling off regional airports? 30 million?
That’s disgusting.
There is that, sure. We’ll probably find out in a few years that they borrowed the dosh off the Congo. Or something. Searches were happening all over town, apparently. A journo mate was told to “move on” when just standing on a pathway on Mountjoy Street. “It’s a public pathway,” he repied to which the cop answered, “well today it’s not”, threatening to arrest him! A lot of peacock feather ruffling and paranoia from our security folk who really aren’t prepared for this and were cacking themselves.
“red-faced culchie Gardaí who’d give their left scrotum to be off-duty milling about with a Hurley stick somewhere bovine-deep in the midlands.”
Oi! Leave us culchies and our lovely complexions out of this!
Hey, I have a very pink face!
It’s a risk alright, but if it goes okay without the radical nationalists ruining things it could be a positive thing.
It baffles me that Elizabeth has been all over the world visiting former colonies and not been to Ireland:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Commonwealth_visits_made_by_Queen_Elizabeth_II
If India can handle its former imperial enemy, surely Ireland can! Anyway I hope all goes well and everyone has a good time of it. Fingers crossed!
(By the way, does Elizabeth also represent all the Commonwealth countries when she visits? Since she’s the head of state of 16 Commonwealth countries as well as the Head of the Commonwealth itself.)
That was the argument all week, that French dignataries met with German ones shortly after WWII and so on, but the seething hatred here, whether understandable or not, is indelible, indissoluble even. Didn’t you hear that mantra growing up here? 800 years 800 years 800 years. And don’t mention the famine. Etc. Interesting to see on the Frontline last night that it’s really the young people who are quite open-minded and progressive, puzzled even that there’s any animosity. It’s a complex bore.
As an adult I’ve rarely come across nationalist anti-British sentiment, but that’s probably just because of the people I happen to know. So I don’t know how strong that sentiment really is. Even Sinn Fein, stronger now that they’ve abandoned militarism, still attract few votes in elections.
Meanwhile a great number of us grew up watching Blue Peter and Grange Hill and stuff! So hopefully a healthy proportion of a generation raised on British football and TV might be able to move past the simplistic naitonal creation myth. I’m pretty optimistic about future relations, really.
Great article.
Can I make a minor point of information? Mountbatten was Prince Philip’s Uncle, not Charlies.
Yes, sorry! Got that wrong, I get totally confused because Queen & Hubby are second cousins and I’m crap about all that, I’ll change now. Thanks!
Extremely enjoyable take on the matter!
One of my mates, a father and small business-owner, was stopped in Dublin SIX TIMES today. All he was doing, or trying to do, was his job.
A man on the radio (presumably from the security operation, but I was only half-listening) advised people to stay away from the city centre except for essential business.
How then is any of this good for Ireland and a boost to the economy and tourism, as we’re being told, unless she bought 30-million quids worth of shamrock tea towels and a feadog?
Good point. Restaurants and other businesses were [rightly] complaining about the loss of business during the visit, especially at a time when they’re barely surviving as it is. It’s certainly not a ‘normal’ state visit, where crowds are out on the roadside cheering (or booing), etc etc., a total feeling of falsification I feel, though everyone on the telly seems to be waxing lyrical about how grea it is for Ireland.
ps. Oops! How rude of me. Nice piece, June (as the garda said to the met police offer).
Erm, officer. I meant officer. See Jennie Kill Her Own Joke.
love it
June, if the Queen was scheduled to visit a gay bar while in Dublin, would you write that she could expect to be greeted by a crowd of mincing hairdressers and butch dykes? If she took in an African barbershop, might she expect to meet smiling picaninnies with thick lips and shiny white teeth? Or would those just be crass stereotypes?
Oh right, Dan, yes I see. As it happens what I described was defo out on the streets yesterday, as it was the day I reported on the Love Ulster riot and as I’m sure we’ll see at Croaker today. I don’t feel any need to double-justify myself to you because you take personal offensive with how I describe what I see. If I saw something else entirely, I would write that. It might be cosier to patronise and lie…but I don’t see the point.
I was out yesterday too. I know there was trouble on Dorset Street but the protest on Parnell Street was peaceful. The protesters were overwhelmingly working class although that is not yet an arrestable offense in and of itself.
It’s quite a feat, you catch a glimpse of Gardai on the street, vagrants in the Garden of Remembrance, demonstrators on Parnell Street and you presume to deduce these peoples’ names, motives and proclivities. Just like that.
If you really went out yesterday and you really didn’t see anything other than crass stereotypes then I put it to you that you weren’t looking very hard. Or maybe weren’t interested in finding anything else.
Judge not lest ye be judged.
I hear that 19 out of 21 arrests yesterday were people with previous connections to the Love Ulster riot. That says a lot. You’re obviously revulsed by what I wrote, which is totally understandable as you disagree with me, but to tell me that I don’t see what I see is another kind of dishonesty all of its own. I also parody Guards in this piece (as I have found security in the run-up to the visit pathetic in parts, asking for people’s names & addresses in particular) as well as the Royals and so on. We live in a democracy where thankfully the maurauding eejits who are too stupid to put dead heroes of the past to bed and perhaps instead create new heroes for the future, have full rights to protest openly as I have full rights to express myself as I see fit here. We all make value judgements in life, to align this to me being similarly ‘homophobic’ or ‘racist’ under other non-existent metaphorical circumstances is lazy and counter-offensive. I’ve nought more to say on this but I want to sincerely thank you for raising the point(s) you did and taking the time to comment. I appreciate all comments and debate is always a positive thing!
You misunderstand me. I’m not pro- Eirigi, not by any stretch of the imagination. Nor was I accusing you of being racist or homophoblic.
The point I was making was that while you wouldn’t dream of making sexist, racist or homophobic remarks, you don’t think twice about making prejudicial remarks about working class people and guards:
“no doubt the tracksuit catwalk will charge like wildebeest towards a line of red-faced culchie Gardai who’d give their left scrotum [???] to be off-duty milling about with a Hurley stick somewhere bovine-deep in the midlands.”
Would you write something as willfully ignorant about black people, gays, Jews, women?
Dan, you don’t have any knowledge of what I would or wouldn’t dream of saying in any given situation as you don’t know me or anything about me. Your line of reasoning is lazy and ludicrous (I see jews and women have now been added to the list). I AM working class by the way and grew up plonk in the middle of one such tracksuit catwalk on the Northside where teenagers were incessantly ‘recruited’ by the cause and brainwashed about Britain being the cause of all our problems…a lot of these kids had to eventually piss off to England to find work when Mother Ireland couldn’t dish up the goods (including myself). I abhor the hypocrisy and I also abhor the thuggery that is so indeliably a part of these protests. The layers and layers of hypocrisy are hilarious and grotesque in equal measure, including the gobshite I saw yesterday roaring “Queen out!” wearing a Liverpool football shirt. I deliberately ‘caricature’ in this piece. You’re asking the same question again that I’ve already answered and to keep whittling on in the same tone is futile and pointless. You don’t like how I wrote this, I respect that. I do not feel any need to justify myself or how I express myself, to you further.
Nice piece, June.
As a lifelong English republican, resident in Dublin 25 years, I wish the whole Royal family would hop off back to Saxe Gotha (wherever that is). Still, from what little I saw, ‘Annie Walker’ (older Corrie viewers will remember) acquitted herself well yesterday and it’s my personal view that gestures of reconciliation, symbolic and otherwise, should be encouraged.
Just as dreams of imperial glory and world cup domination are damaging to England’s national psyche so are brooding about 800 years and setting grudges in stone damaging to Ireland’s.
We (the inhabitants of this country) should be concerning ourselves more with the next 800 days.
Mick, I agree with all that! My sentiments on a plate exactly. I’ve no time for the retrospective rebel adoring. The future seems already too urgent and in need of our attention. As far as moments of reconciliation go, I felt a tingle of sorts hearing a very elderly UK monarch have a go at some words As Gaeilge! That was an amazing moment. McAleese did a great speech too, I thought. It seems there wasn’t that much ‘protesting’ at all. The most was last night up and around the Liberties, a crowd of about 500 (or 449 if you subtract the amount of nouveau rebels wearing UK-teams football shirts). I thought there’d be more of a hoo-haw at Garden of Remembrance. Let’s hope she makes it safely to Cork and doesn’t end up starring in a Michael Collins On Cork Roads part II flick.
Buggar, that word was meant to be ‘subtract’ and not ‘subject’, unfortunately I cannot edit my own posts at this time.
Duly fixed!
Thanks…
Every time I see the Queen, I am reminded of the exchange between Blackadder (the Third) and Le Comte de Frou Frou:
Blackadder: Would you like to earn some money?
CdFF: No, I wouldn’t. I would like other people to earn it, and then give it to me.
Leaving aside the ridiculous hyperbole about history which has accompanied this visit – it is important, but not nearly as significant as commentators breathlessly claim – the most cynical and hypocritical moment came last night when HM the Queen said in her speech:
“The challenges of the past have been replaced by new economic challenges which will demand the same imagination and courage. The lessons from the peace process are clear; whatever life throws at us, our individual responses will be all the stronger for working together and sharing the load.”
Sharing the load? While she wears a tiara that probably costs more than my car, or even my house? While €30 million is being spent on her visit at the same time as Rape Crisis Network Ireland has to beg not to have its core funding (a paltry €270,000) slashed? And is the courage she mentions the same as that of Brian Lenihan Jr, who courageously took from the poor and gave to the rich? Creating a society where, as Alan Moore once said, the top ten percent will be better off, the bottom ten per cent better off dead?
Seeing as the man sitting beside her, David Cameron, is enthusiastically trying to recreate Victorian levels of inequality in Britain by demolishing and privatising as many of the supports for the poor and vulnerable as he can, while favouring at every turn his vastly rich banking and business cronies, did she mean to say: “…by dumping the load on to the poor, the vulnerable, the disabled, and the elderly, on to children and the mentally ill, on anyone other than the wealthy and powerful, because they’re inherently superior to the plebs in every way, just like me.”
Well said Jonathan.
The queen cynical? I doubt it. The monarchy system is bizarre to me – the excess and the idea of mere bloodlines entitling someone to have a large hand in ruling a nation. But we can hardly expect them to abolish themselves.
And I don’t think any of us here can take the moral high ground when it comes to financial privilege and inequality. One quarter of the worlds population doesn’t have electricity (so I guess they don’t read blogs very often). One fifth of us are consuming over 75% of the resources that should be shared among us all.
We need to fix our own lifestyles first.
[...] This post originally appeared on the Anti Room blog in May 2011 – to read the comments click here [...]